Community Finds: Kevin’s Stunning Inheritance — A Pristine 1970s Stitzel-Weller “Old Fitzgerald’s 1849” 10-Year Bourbon
When it comes to finding elite vintage bourbon, the ultimate golden ticket is anything carrying a “Shively, Kentucky” address. Reader Kevin reached out with an extraordinary piece of family history passed down from his father. The bottle had been quietly resting at room temperature inside a dark cupboard or pantry for decades—the absolute ideal environment for long-term preservation.
Kevin knew the basics from reading the glass: it is 90 proof and a traditional 4/5 quart (the historic “fifth”). However, he wanted to know the deeper history and a realistic valuation of what his dad left behind.
The Rebellion Against 100 Proof: The History of “1849”
To understand why this bottle makes vintage spirits collectors lose their minds, you have to look at the philosophy of the legendary distillery founder, Julian “Pappy” Van Winkle.
As long as Pappy ran the Stitzel-Weller Distillery, he fiercely resisted ever bottling his flagship Old Fitzgerald label at anything below 100 proof. He famously argued that if a customer wanted a lower-proof bourbon, they should add their own water at home rather than paying him to dilute it at the plant.
However, following Pappy’s passing in 1965, the American palate shifted dramatically toward lighter, lower-proof spirits. Under immense pressure to compete, his son and successor, Julian Van Winkle II, formulated a brilliant compromise in the late 1960s/early 1970s: Old Fitzgerald’s 1849.
Named after the year that legendary distributor W.L. Weller & Sons was originally founded, this 90-proof line extension allowed the distillery to offer a smoother, lighter alternative while retaining their world-famous, intensely soft wheated mashbill.
Anatomy of Kevin’s Pantry Find
Looking closely, we can precisely date and evaluate the masterpiece Kevin’s father tucked away:
-
The Age Statement: While many later iterations of 1849 were dropped to an 8-year age statement, Kevin’s bottle features the highly coveted red and gold shield on the neck proudly proclaiming “10 Years Old”. This indicates it was distilled in the early-to-mid 1960s—the true “Golden Age” of Stitzel-Weller production.
-
The Gold Foil Top: The long, gold-wrapped neck foil reads “Very Old Fitzgerald” underneath the distinct embossed “Stitzel-Weller” logo, a signature styling cue of early 1970s bottlings.
-
Immaculate Preservation: Because Kevin’s dad kept this inside a cupboard away from sunlight and drastic temperature swings, the condition is spectacular. The labels are crisp, the gold foil is unbroken, and the liquid fill line is incredibly high, sitting perfectly at the lower neck with virtually zero evaporation over 50 years.
What Is It Worth?
Wheated bourbon distilled during the Van Winkle era at Stitzel-Weller is among the most sought-after liquid on earth. Collectors hunt for these specific 10-year iterations because they showcase how beautifully the soft, wheated recipe handles extended time in charred oak.
-
Auction Valuation: At specialized spirits auctions, a 1970s Stitzel-Weller Old Fitz 1849 10-Year in this beautiful condition consistently commands between $1,500 and $2,000 + buyer’s premium.
-
Specialty Retail Valuation: If you were to buy this exact bottle from a high-end vintage spirits broker or archive boutique, it routinely commands between $2,500 and $3,300+.
It is an incredibly valuable, rare, and historic bottle of whiskey that represents the absolute peak of American distilling craftsmanship. Kevin’s father left him an extraordinary piece of liquid history!
Did your father or grandfather leave behind a hidden liquid legacy of his own?
If you’ve inherited an old bottle or found a decades-old “fifth” tucked away in a family pantry, we are ready to help you read the glass. Send your photos over to our Whiskey Bottle Evaluation Form and let’s discover the history—and value—hiding in your cupboards together!
